Pa3553 Firewire port speed

Moderator: ModTeam

hfivefour
Posts: 5
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 15:40
Product(s): Amilo PA 3353

Pa3553 Firewire port speed

Postby hfivefour » Tue Mar 15, 2011 20:33

My son has a Pa3553. Apart from quality one of the criteria was firewire for loading videos.

He is now thinking about getting an external drive.

As I understand (maybe wrongly) a firewire 400 (1394a) is not much different in speed to USB2.0.

However firewire 800 or 1394b is.

We cannot work out what version is 1394a or 1394b is on the pa3553.

Does anyone know or provide pointers in the system.

TIA
Andrew

otheos
Posts: 47
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2009 10:59
Product(s): Amilo Pa3553

Re: Pa3553 Firewire port speed

Postby otheos » Sat May 14, 2011 16:29

The Pa3553 has an 1394a port, not b, i.e. 400Mbit/sec.

However this is considerably faster than USB2.0 which although advertises a similar speed, it is severely capped by overhead, which limits the transfer speed to only 25MB/s. On top of that seek speed of hard drives connected through USB is also severely affected.

Firewire on the other hand is much faster, all the advertised bandwidth is available (almost 50MB/s) and seek times are as fast as if connected using SATA/PATA.

So Firewire is always better than USB, if you can find a drive with a 1394 port, go for it instead of a USB2.0 drive.

However E-Sata is even better and the Pa-3553 has one of those too. Just make sure you buy a device that supports "power by E-Sata" which means it uses the E-Sata connection for data and the surrounding USB port for power. This can be tricky. (E-Sata doesn't provide power and an external power supply is required otherwise).


Return to “AMILO Notebook”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests