Postby qwertz » Sun Aug 23, 2009 19:54
After an inspection and without offering a clear opinion, the dealer agreed during the week of 13 July 2009 to return the computer to Fujitsu’s service provider. It was understood that the operating system should only be reinstalled if necessary. I received the computer back on 10 August 2009. In the absence of a service report attached by Fujitsu’s service provider, the dealer told me that the computer’s motherboard had been replaced, but no further details were available. When I arrived back home, I found out that my English version of Vista had been replaced with a different language version and all my third-party applications had disappeared.
I thus restored the English version of Vista with my Fujitsu Siemens Computers Recovery disks. Thereafter, I started to redownload and to reinstall my third-party applications (Firefox, Thunderbird, Easeus Partition Master, AVG Free, Open Office – still remaining to be installed), and the computer worked fine from 10 to 15 August: it no longer produced the annoying rattling sound; there were no more boot freezes; the PC went into sleep mode without protest. On 16 August, without prior warning, trouble resurfaced: the boot process resumed its random freezing behaviour as before (instead of loading Windows Vista, the computer freezes after the “Checking NVRAM..” message and the Microsoft Windows load bar doesn’t appear); at random again and instead of falling into sleep mode, the computer goes to the same window as the one that appears when one hits Ctrl-Alt-Delete, locking itself up (one needs to key in the user’s password in order to reaccess the computer) but without falling asleep. Boot freezing only occurs when the BIOS is set to the “Optimized Defaults” mode (11 out of 20 times on 17 August; 13 out of 20 times on 20 August). When the BIOS is set to the “Fail-Safe Defaults” mode, the computer always starts normally.
When I recontacted my dealer, he explained that Fujitsu would refuse to replace the computer with a new one before a minimum three repairs would eventually prove to be unsuccessful. Once agreement on a replacement would be reached, the cost of the license for Windows Vista would need to be absorbed by the dealer. He recommended I should not simply use the computer with the BIOS set to the “Fail-Safe Defaults” mode, suggesting that I should restore Windows Vista one more time to see if the problems would disappear. Depending on the result, my dealer would then return the computer to Fujitsu for a third repair attempt, or else he would add a few RAM sticks to see if that would resolve the problems permanently.
I restored the factory default settings and held my breath... The computer worked fine after the restore: no more boot freezes, no more trouble when it is time to put it to bed. That said, I noticed that Vista’s Advanced Tools Event Log has generated 88 (warning/critical/error) events as a result of my restoring and testing the operating system on 20 August 2009. In addition, Vista displayed a “Safely Remove Hardware” icon (USB Mass Storage Device at Port #9, Hub #2 allocated to the computer’s memory card slots) although I didn’t use the slots after the restore and there was nothing to remove from them. On 21 August I took the computer back to the dealer for another inspection and I am awaiting the verdict now.
So how reliable is Fujitsu’s Technical Support? I my opinion the team’s performance has been lacklustre at best:
* Technical Support’s online contact form comes along with the statement that the team “aim to respond within one working day”, claiming that “it may still be necessary to complete further diagnostics with the helpdesk team who will respond to you within one working day”. There have been too many instances in my case where the one-day time frame has been exceeded.
* The team’s performance seems to be hampered by bad coordination. In one instance, my interlocutor had relied on a “2nd line department” to contact me. That contact never took place and I had to remind the help desk that I was still awaiting an answer.
* The help desk was mixing up replacement policies for spare parts between several markets.
* The help desk’s technical knowledge appears to be limited:
° Version 2 of the DIFS diagnostics tool that Technical Support asked me to use on 9 July 2009 never worked on my computer. My dealer told me that version 2 of the tool is not meant to be used on my Amilo Pi 3630 and that version 3 is the right version for my computer.
° Except for one early suspicion that my problems may have been due to a faulty graphics card and/or motherboard, Technical Support never offered any specific technical opinion. Rather than providing concrete technical advice, the help desk appears to act as a mere intermediary between Fujitsu’s service provider (the repair agent) and the end user.
* In July Technical Support insisted that I need to reinstall the computer’s operating system before they could accept a second repair order. The reason invoked was that they needed to ensure the problems are not caused by the operating system or by third party software.
Meanwhile, the computer’s graphics card and the motherboard have been exchanged, but the computer still presented booting problems a few days after an initial restore of the operating system. Now let’s remember that booting only froze when the BIOS was set to the “Optimized Defaults” mode (and not when it was set to the “Fail-Safe Defaults” mode), and even when freezing occurred it did not happen every time, but at random every second time or so. Let’s also remember that Windows Vista generated a significant number of (warning/critical/error) events just after restoring it a second time and, in addition, the computer’s memory card slots trigger a meaningless removal message. I am using standard peripherals (56K modem, printer, two external hard drives) and no unusual third-party software, and the six USB ports on the computer’s back panel are in use. – Could it thus be that, with a growing size of the computer’s operating system, its motherboard (MS-7504VP-PV) and the BIOS (AMI V3.0L) simply can’t cope with the strain? Knowing that 4 GB of RAM (i.e the upper limit that can be used by the 32-bit version of Vista Home Premium) is already installed, could the addition of more RAM solve the recurring problems? Or could there be a more fundamental problem with the motherboard’s design and/or the BIOS settings?
I bought my Pi 3630 four and a half months ago, and it has been out for repair or inspection three times during a total five weeks by now. Going forward, I have decided to handle the matter straight with my dealer instead of contacting Fujitsu’s Technical Support team.